MG Astor vs Tata Punch EV
Do you want to find out which car is the best, MG Astor or Tata Punch EV? 91Wheels brings you a detailed comparison between Astor and Punch EV. MG Astor Price starts at Rs.9.98 Lakh (ex-showroom) for Sprint VTI - Tech 5 MT and Tata Punch EV Price starts at Rs.10.99 Lakh (ex-showroom) for Smart 3.3. MG Astor is 4 cylinder, 1498 cc Engine can generate 108.49 bhp @ 6000 power whereas Tata Punch EV can generate N/A power. In terms of mileage, Astor provides a mileage of 15.43 kmpl (base model), and Punch EV has a range of 315 km/charge (base model).
Astor vs Punch EV
| Key Highlights | MG Astor | Tata Punch EV |
|---|---|---|
| Price | Rs.9.98 Lakh | Rs.10.99 Lakh |
| Engine Capacity | 1498 cc | N/A |
| Power | 108.49 bhp @ 6000 | N/A |
| Mileage/Range | 15.43 kmpl | 315 km/charge |
+ Add Car 3 |
Specifications Overview
| Astor specifications | Punch EV specifications | ||
|---|---|---|---|
| Variant Name | |||
| On Road Price | 11.16 Lakh Price Breakup | 11.63 Lakh Price Breakup | |
| Fuel Type | Petrol | Electric | |
| User Rating | |||
| Boot Space (Litres) | 488 Litres | 366 Litres | |
| Transmission Type | Manual | Automatic | |
| Engine Displacement | 1498 cc | - | |
| Max Power (bhp @rpm) | 108.49 bhp @ 6000 | - | |
| Colors | |||
| Images |
Brakes, Suspension & Tyres
| Astor Brakes, Suspension & Tyres | Punch EV Brakes, Suspension & Tyres | ||
|---|---|---|---|
Front Suspension | MacPherson Strut | Independent, Lower Wishbone, McPherson Strut with Coil Spring | |
Rear Suspension | Torsion Beam | Semi-independent Twist Beam With Coil Spring And Shock Absorber | |
Front Brakes | Disc | Disc | |
Rear Brakes | Disc | Drum | |
Wheels | Steel Rims | Steel Rims | |
Spare Wheel | Steel | Steel | |
Front Tyre Size | 215/55 R17 | 185/70 R15 | |
Rear Tyre Size | 215/55 R17 | 185/70 R15 | |
Turning Radius | 5.6 meters | 5 meters | |
Tyre Size Spare | 215/60 R16 | - | |
Wheels Size | R17 | R15 |
Exterior
| Astor Exterior | Punch EV Exterior | ||
|---|---|---|---|
Sunroof | No | No | |
Power Windows | Front & Rear | Front Only | |
Adjustable ORVMs | Electrically Adjustable | Internally Adjustable | |
Turn Indicators on ORVMs | Yes | Yes | |
Rear Wiper | Yes | No | |
Rear Defogger | Yes | No | |
Bootlid Opener | Electric Tailgate Release | Electric Tailgate Release | |
Rain Sensing Wipers | No | No | |
Daytime Running Lights | LED | Not Sure | |
LED headlight | Yes | Yes | |
Projector headlight | No | No | |
Automatic Headlamps | No | No | |
Follow Me Home Headlamps | Yes | No |
Instrumentation
| Astor Instrumentation | Punch EV Instrumentation | ||
|---|---|---|---|
Low Fuel Level Warning | Yes | Yes | |
Adjustable Cluster Brightness | Yes | No | |
Gear Indicator | Yes | No | |
Shift Indicator | No | No | |
Tachometer | Digital | Analogue | |
Speedometer | - | Digital | |
Avg fuel economy display | Yes | Yes |
Infotainment & Communication
| Astor Infotainment & Communication | Punch EV Infotainment & Communication | ||
|---|---|---|---|
Apple CarPlay | Yes | No | |
Android Auto | Yes | No | |
Voice Command | Yes | No | |
Infotainment Screen | Yes + 10 inch | Yes | |
Multifunction Display | Yes | No | |
Touchscreen Size | 10.1 Inch | - | |
Display Screen for Rear Passengers | No | - | |
Bluetooth Compatibility | Yes | No | |
Gesture Control | No | - | |
Integrated Music System | Yes | No | |
Speakers | 4 | No | |
AM/FM Radio | Yes | No | |
USB Compatibility | Yes | No | |
Wireless Charger | No | No | |
Basic Warranty | - | 3 Year or 125000 km |
Engine & Transmission
| Astor Engine & Transmission | Punch EV Engine & Transmission | ||
|---|---|---|---|
Engine Capacity | 1498 cc | - | |
Engine Type | VTi-TECH 1.5 | Permanent Magnet Synchronous Motor | |
No. of Cylinders | 4 | - | |
No. of valves per cylinder | 4 | - | |
Fuel Type | Petrol | Electric | |
Transmission Type | Manual | Automatic | |
Gears | 5 Gears | 1 Gears | |
Power | 108.49 bhp @ 6000 | - | |
Torque | 144 Nm @ 4400 rpm | 114 Nm | |
Battery Capacity | - | 25 kwh | |
Battery Type | - | Lithium Ion | |
Charging Time | - | 9.4 Hours | |
Drivetrain | FWD | FWD | |
ARAI Certified Economy | 15.43 kmpl | - | |
Range | - | 315 km/charge |
Comfort & Convenience
| Astor Comfort & Convenience | Punch EV Comfort & Convenience | ||
|---|---|---|---|
AC | Yes | Yes | |
Rear AC Vents | Blower& Vents Behind Front Armrest | - | |
Automatic climate control | Yes | Yes | |
Heater | Yes | Yes | |
Vanity Mirrors on Sun Visors | Driver & Co-Driver | No | |
Cruise Control | No | No | |
Start / Stop Button | No | No | |
Power Steering | Yes | Yes | |
Adjustable steering | Yes | Yes | |
Multifunction Steering Wheel | Yes | Yes | |
Leather streering wheels | Yes | No | |
Drive Modes | - | 2 | |
Keyless Entry | Yes | No | |
Electronic Parking Brake | No | No | |
Parking Assist | No | No |
Safety
| Astor Safety | Punch EV Safety | ||
|---|---|---|---|
NCAP Rating | Not Tested | Not Tested | |
Airbags | 2 | 6 | |
ISOFIX (Child-Seat Mount) | Yes | Yes | |
Overspeed Warning | 1 beep over 80kmph& Continuous beeps over 120kmph | 1 beep over 80kmph, Continuous beeps over 120kmph | |
ABS (Anti-lock Braking System) | Yes | Yes | |
EBD (Electronic Brake-force Distribution) | Yes | Yes | |
EBA (Electronic Brake Assist) | Yes | Yes | |
ESP (Electronic Stability Program) | Yes | Yes | |
ASR / Traction Control | Yes | No | |
Tyre Pressure Monitoring System | Yes | Yes | |
Lane Departure Warning | No | No | |
Emergency Brake Light Flashing | Yes | No | |
Seat Belt Warning | Yes | Yes | |
Rear Middle Three Point seatbelt | Yes | No | |
Rear Middle Head Rest | Yes | No |
Dimensions & Capacity
| Astor Dimensions & Capacity | Punch EV Dimensions & Capacity | ||
|---|---|---|---|
Length | 4323 mm | 3857 mm | |
Width | 1809 mm | 1742 mm | |
Height | 1650 mm | 1633 mm | |
Wheelbase | 2585 mm | 2445 mm | |
Ground Clearance | - | 190 mm | |
No. of Seats | 5 | 5 | |
No. of Doors | 5 | 5 | |
Fuel Tank Capacity | 48 Litres | - | |
Engine Oil Capacity | 5 Litres | - | |
Boot Space | 488 Litres | 366 Litres | |
Kerb Weight | 1303 kg | - | |
Body Type | SUV | SUV |
Pros & Cons
| Astor Pros & Cons | Punch EV Pros & Cons | ||
|---|---|---|---|
Pros |
| ||
Cons |
|
Which Car Do You Like More ?
Detailed Comparison of MG Astor and Tata Punch EV
Safety
Astor comes loaded with ISOFIX (Child-Seat Mount), ABS (Anti-lock Braking System), EBD (Electronic Brake-force Distribution), EBA (Electronic Brake Assist), ESP (Electronic Stability Program), ASR / Traction Control, Tyre Pressure Monitoring System, Emergency Brake Light Flashing, Seat Belt Warning, Rear Middle Three Point seatbelt, Rear Middle Head Rest, Hill Assist, Hill Descent Control, Engine Immobiliser, Speed Sensing Door Lock, Child Safety Lock, Door Ajar Warning. Punch EV has ISOFIX (Child-Seat Mount), ABS (Anti-lock Braking System), EBD (Electronic Brake-force Distribution), EBA (Electronic Brake Assist), ESP (Electronic Stability Program), Tyre Pressure Monitoring System, Seat Belt Warning, Hill Assist, Engine Immobiliser, Speed Sensing Door Lock, Child Safety Lock, Door Ajar Warning.
Transmission
MG Astor comes with FWD and 5 Gears Manual transmission. And Punch EV comes with FWD and 1 Gears Automatic transmission.
Astor Similar Car Comparisons
MGAstor₹ 9.98 - ₹ 17.90 Lakh*
HyundaiVenue N Line₹ 12.08 - ₹ 13.90 Lakh*- MGAstor₹ 9.98 - ₹ 17.90 Lakh*
Maruti SuzukiGrand Vitara₹ 10.80 - ₹ 20.09 Lakh* - MGAstor₹ 9.98 - ₹ 17.90 Lakh*
MahindraScorpio Classic₹ 13.59 - ₹ 17.35 Lakh*
Punch EV Similar Car Comparisons
TataPunch EV₹ 10.99 - ₹ 15.49 Lakh*
MahindraXUV 400 Electric₹ 15.49 - ₹ 19.39 Lakh*
MG Astor and Tata Punch EV Owner Reviews
View All User Review For Astor
MG Astor and Tata Punch EV FAQs
What is the on-road price of MG Astor?
The on-road price of MG Astor is Rs. 11.16 Lakh in New Delhi.
What is the on-road price of Tata Punch EV?
The on-road price of Tata Punch EV is Rs. 11.63 Lakh in New Delhi.