Simple Energy One vs Ather 450S
Do you want to find out which scooter is the best, Simple Energy One or Ather 450S? 91Wheels brings you a detailed comparison between One and 450S. Simple Energy One Price starts at Rs.1.70 Lakh (ex-showroom) for Gen 2 4.5kWh and Ather 450S Price starts at Rs.1.23 Lakh (ex-showroom) for IDC range 122 Km. Simple Energy One can generate N/A power whereas Ather 450S can generate N/A power. In terms of range, One provides a range of 236km/charge (base model), and 450S has a range of 122km/charge (base model). Simple Energy One is available in 9 colours & 4 variants whereas Ather 450S is available in 4 colours & 3 variants.
One vs 450S
| Key Highlights | Simple One | Ather 450S |
|---|---|---|
| Price | Rs.1.70 Lakh | Rs.1.23 Lakh |
| Engine Capacity | N/A | N/A |
| Power | N/A | N/A |
| Mileage/Range | 236 km/charge | 122 km/charge |
Ad
Specifications Overview
| One specifications | 450S specifications | Roadster X specifications | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Variant Name | |||
| On Road Price | 1.77 Lakh Price Breakup | 1.31 Lakh Price Breakup | 1.04 Lakh Price Breakup |
| User Rating | 4.1 | 4.4 | 4.2 |
| Transmission Type | Automatic | Automatic | Automatic |
Ad
Add your vehicle to our online garage
- Free valuation of your vehicle
- 1Mn+ users joined our Community
- 10+ experts to give advice
Which vehicle do you own?
Select your vehicle
Add vehicle
Brakes, Suspension & Tyres
| One Brakes, Suspension & Tyres | 450S Brakes, Suspension & Tyres | Roadster X Brakes, Suspension & Tyres | |
|---|---|---|---|
Braking System | CBS | CBS | Single Channel ABS |
Calliper Type | Fixed | - | - |
Front Disc Size | 200 | 200 | - |
Front Suspension Preload Adjuster | No | No | No |
Front Wheel Size | R12 | R12 | R18 |
Rear Suspension Preload Adjuster | No | No | No |
Rear Wheel Size | R12 | R12 | R17 |
Wheel Type | Alloy | Alloy | Alloy |
Front Suspension | Telescopic Fork | Telescopic Forks | Telescopic |
Rear Suspension | Mono Shock | Symmetrically Mounted Progressive MoNoshock | Twin Shock |
Front Tyre Size | 90/90 - R12 | 90/90 - R12 | 80/100 R18 |
Rear Tyre Size | 90/90 - R12 | 100/80-R12 | 100/90 R17 |
Front Brake | Disc | Disc | Drum |
Rear Disc/Drum Size | 190 mm | 190 mm | - |
Rear Brake | Disc | Disc | Drum |
Instrumentation
| One Instrumentation | 450S Instrumentation | Roadster X Instrumentation | |
|---|---|---|---|
Riding Modes Switch | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Touch Screen Display | Yes | No | No |
Fuel level guage | Digital | Digital | Digital |
Tachometer | Digital | No | Digital |
Speedometer | Digital | Digital | Digital |
Odometer | Digital | Digital | Digital |
Exterior
| One Exterior | 450S Exterior | Roadster X Exterior | |
|---|---|---|---|
Daytime Running Lights | Yes | Yes | Yes |
LED headlight | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Warranty
| One Warranty | 450S Warranty | Roadster X Warranty | |
|---|---|---|---|
Basic Warranty | 3 Years/30000 Kms | 3Years/30000 kms Battery Warranty. 3Years/30000 kms Motor warranty. 3Years Charger Warranty | 3 Years/50000 Kms |
Body & Suspension
| One Body & Suspension | 450S Body & Suspension | Roadster X Body & Suspension | |
|---|---|---|---|
Colors | |||
Images | |||
Frame Type | Tubular | Precision Machined Hybrid Chassis | Double Cradle |
Engine & Transmission
| One Engine & Transmission | 450S Engine & Transmission | Roadster X Engine & Transmission | |
|---|---|---|---|
Transmission Type | Automatic | Automatic | Automatic |
Battery Capacity | 4.5 kwh | 2.9 kwh | 2.5 kwh |
Battery Type | Lithium Ion | Lithium Ion | Lithium ion |
Charging Time | 2 Hours & 15 Mins | 5 hours 30 mins (0-80%) | 6 Hours & 12 Min (0-80%) |
Fast Charging | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Range | 236 km/charge | 122 km/charge | 140 km/charge |
Top Speed | 90 kmph | 90 kmph | 105 kmph |
Acceleration | - | - | 3.4sec (0-40km/h) |
Charging Socket | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Max Torque | 52 Nm | 22 Nm | - |
Motor Power | 6400 W | 5400 W | 7000 W |
Comfort & Convenience
| One Comfort & Convenience | 450S Comfort & Convenience | Roadster X Comfort & Convenience | |
|---|---|---|---|
Average Speed Indicator | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Call/SMS Alerts | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Front Storage Box | - | No | No |
Geo Fencing | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Low Battery Indicator | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Pillion Backrest | No | No | No |
Pillion Footrest | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Riding Modes | 6 | 4 | 3 |
Service Reminder Indicator | - | - | Yes |
Under Seat Storage | 35 | 22 | 3.27 |
GPS & Navigation | Yes | Yes | No |
Console Type | Digital | Digital | Digital |
Distance to Empty Indicator | Yes | No | Yes |
Engine Kill Switch | Yes | No | - |
Instrument Console | Digital | Digital | Digital |
Safety
| One Safety | 450S Safety | Roadster X Safety | |
|---|---|---|---|
AHO (Automatic Headlight On) | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Hazard Warning Indicator | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Hazard Warning Switch | No | No | Yes |
Radial Tyres | No | No | - |
Side Stand Alarm | No | Yes | Yes |
Pass Light | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Pillion Grabrail | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Turn Signal | LED | LED | LED |
ABS - Anti-lock braking system | No | No | Yes |
Power Modes | Yes | 4 | - |
Traction Control System | - | Yes | No |
Dimensions & Capacity
| One Dimensions & Capacity | 450S Dimensions & Capacity | Roadster X Dimensions & Capacity | |
|---|---|---|---|
Length | 1907 mm | 1891 mm | 2015 mm |
Width | 758 mm | 739 mm | 831 mm |
Height | 1163 mm | 1114 mm | - |
Wheelbase | 1347 mm | 1296 mm | 1301.9 mm |
Ground Clearance | 172 mm | 170 mm | - |
Body Type | Scooter | Scooter | Commuter |
Seat Height | 780 mm | 780 mm | 777 mm |
Unladden/Kerb Weight | 126 kg | 108 kg | 123.4 kg |
Entertainment & Communication
| One Entertainment & Communication | 450S Entertainment & Communication | Roadster X Entertainment & Communication | |
|---|---|---|---|
MID (Multi Info Display) | - | - | Yes |
Pros & Cons
| One Pros & Cons | 450S Pros & Cons | Roadster X Pros & Cons | |
|---|---|---|---|
Pros |
| - | |
Cons |
| - |
Ad
Detailed Comparison of Simple One and Ather 450S
Safety
One comes loaded with No ABS - Anti-lock braking system, AHO (Automatic Headlight On), Hazard Warning Indicator, Pass Light, Pillion Grabrail, Power Modes. 450S has Pillion Grabrail, Side Stand Alarm, Hazard Warning Indicator, AHO (Automatic Headlight On), Pass Light, Traction Control System.
Comfort & Convenience
Simple Energy One has features like Average Speed Indicator, Call/SMS Alerts, Geo Fencing, Low Battery Indicator, Pillion Footrest, GPS & Navigation, Distance to Empty Indicator, Engine Kill Switch, Side Stand Indicator, USB Charger Port and Ather 450S, on the other hand, has Geo Fencing, Average Speed Indicator, Call/SMS Alerts, Pillion Footrest, Low Battery Indicator, GPS & Navigation, Side Stand Indicator.
One Similar Scooter Comparisons
Simple EnergyOne₹ 1.70 - ₹ 1.78 Lakh*
Ola ElectricS1 Pro Gen 3₹ 1.25 - ₹ 1.90 Lakh*
450S Similar Scooter Comparisons
Ad
Simple One and Ather 450S and Ola Electric Roadster X Owner Reviews
View All User Review For OneAd
Simple One and Ather 450S FAQs
What is the on-road price of Simple One?
The on-road price of Simple One is Rs. 1.77 Lakh in New Delhi.
What is the on-road price of Ather 450S?
The on-road price of Ather 450S is Rs. 1.31 Lakh in New Delhi.